The Argyle Theatre’s Guide to Restaurant Dining in Babylon, NY

From juicy burgers and pizza to family-style and fine dining eateries, you’ll find delicious restaurant and dining options at popular restaurants near the Historic Argyle Theatre in Babylon Village.

These are some of the local Babylon Restaurant & Dining favorites:

Babylon Burger Bar
1 W. Main Street
Babylon Village, NY

Babylon Burger Bar offers a variety of homemade prime beef burgers cooked to order, hand-cut fries, hand-spun super milkshakes, appetizers, salads, and desserts. This family-friendly spot offers a full bar with local drafts and crafted cocktails.

Babylon Carriage House
21 Fire Island Avenue
Babylon Village, NY

Babylon Carriage House offer a varied menu of appetizers, delicious “Land and Sea” options like Pan Seared Salmon and Parmesan Crusted Chicken, sandwiches, and desserts. The bar is busy and has a popular Happy Hour.

Cafe Il Villaggio
35 Deer Park Avenue
Babylon Village, NY

A family-owned restaurant for over 23 years, Café Il Villaggio offers a creative mix of both traditional and eclectic Italian dishes like Linguine al Pescatore and Gnocchi Genovese in a fine-dining setting.

Horace & Sylvia’s Publick House
100 Deer Park Avenue
Babylon Village, NY

Homey American bistro features seasonal menus with fresh, local ingredients, creative dishes like Espresso Dusted Grilled Shrimp and Fig and Gruyere Chicken, Long Island wines, and a friendly bar with 24 tap beers.

La Famiglia
90 W. Main Street
Babylon Village, NY

La Famiglia offers family-style dining (each dish serves 2-3 people). Italian menu features chicken, veal, and seafood entrees and signature pasta dishes like Penne Siciliana and Linguini Seafood Combo.

48 Deer Park Avenue
Babylon Village, NY

In an ultra-chic modern setting with an electrified bar area, Monsoon Asian Steak & Sushi showcases a refined blend of Vietnamese, Japanese, Chinese and Thai cuisines—resulting in scrumptious dishes like Lemongrass Braised Short Ribs and Kung Pao Monkfish.

Post Office Café
130 W. Main Street
Babylon Village, NY

A Long Island favorite for over 40 years, the Post Office Café offers American pub food and craft beers in an old post office building buzzing with happy-hour and sports-bar crowds. The eatery is known for their juicy burgers, signature cocktails, and welcoming staff.

Enjoy dinner before the performance at these popular restaurants near the Historic Argyle Theatre in Babylon Village, NY.


Courtyard Marriott Islip
11 Courthouse Drive,
Central Islip, NY

The all-new Courtyard by Marriott in Islip, Long Island, New York in Suffolk County is a 10-minute drive from downtown Babylon Village. Spacious, new guest rooms offer SMART televisions, wireless internet, great work space, and a perfect night sleep, heated indoor pool, fitness center, and a full working business center.